The Infinitely Stranger Cases of Sherlock Holmes by Paula Hammond
Around the World in 80,000 Pages - Book 27
The Infinitely Stranger Cases of Sherlock Holmes by Paula Hammond
You can read about my Around the World in 80,000 Pages challenge here.
Miles travelled: 1,276
Pages read: 9,495
I stated at the outset that I reserved the right to be liberal in my interpretation of 'setting' and I hereby invoke such prerogatives. This collection of short Holmesian stories takes place in various locales, but one of them is Llandudno, which is the home of the author. And so, for the purposes of this challenge, we are now in Llandudno.
I have written before about the two options open to authors writing new Sherlock Holmes stories. The first is to write as if they were Doyle, continuing the canon. The second is to do something new and interesting with the character. This collection falls firmly in the former category.
Paula Hammond takes the lead from tales such as Hound of the Baskervilles and The Sussex Vampire, where initially a supernatural explanation seems to offer itself, but soon withers under the steely gaze of the world's greatest detective. Nothing new is added to the Holmesian milieu, which frankly is a relief (and I say this as the author of a comic series where Holmes is a vampire...). I am firmly of the opinion that if you are going down the canonical route, nothing major should be added nor taken away.
Hammond gets the tone pretty much spot on. The Infinitely Stranger Cases is like revisiting old friends. They haven't changed a bit, which is all to the good. The mysteries are coherent and solved by Holmes' talents. I would have liked the stories to be a little longer, so the mystery has time to sit for a while, and a few more red herrings could have been thrown in.
Overall, if you like the original Sherlock Holmes stories, I highly recommend this book. There are few instances of such a faithful continuation of the canon. With 98/140, it garners ★★★★☆
Our flag is still that of Merionthshire, which is still incorrect for the setting, but what can you do...goats. And the suggested music is a solo vilin rendition of the traditional welsh tune Gruffydd ap Cynan, performed by Sian Phillips.




Comments
Post a Comment