The Library Suicides by Fflur Dafydd
Around the World in 80,000 Pages - Book 24
The Library Suicides by Fflur Dafydd
You can read about my Around the World in 80,000 Pages challenge here.
Miles travelled: 1,197
Pages read: 8,779
Heading up the west coast of Wales we reach Aberystwyth.
![]() |
| Photo by Jeremy Segrott, used under Creative Commons license |
Fflur Dafydd is a Welsh novelist, screenwriter, singer-songwriter and musician. She generally writes in Welsh, but has some work (such as The Library Suicides) in English.
Dafydd wrote Y Llyfrgell (The Library), a Welsh language novel in 2009, and rewrote it in English as The Library Suicides, reinterpreting it rather than just translating it.
When I was choosing my Welsh books I seem to remember thinking The Library Suicides was described as literary fiction. When it arrived in the post I was surprised by how 'genre' the cover looked. Reading it, it becomes obvious the book has a finger in each pie. Normally, I am a big fan of works that combine genre and literary fiction. Unfortunately, the blend here didn't really work for me. I found the world building clunky. The Library Suicides is set in a near-future dystopia. However, it felt exactly like our world, with a few incongruous details bolted in. There has been a shift towards a radical feminism, but this is not represented in any of the characters' attitudes and is only mentioned as a kind of, by the way... It doesn't help that the world building only seems to come into play to explain what would otherwise be a gapping plot hole, there are no little details to support the setting.
Y Llyfrgell was explicitly set in Aberustwyth, but for The Library Suicides Dadydd strips out the names of all places, but I can't quite work out why. Was she trying to give it a universality that she felt would otherwise be lacking? I'm not sure Wales is foreign enough to most people to cause an issue in this regard. Wales is referred to throughout as 'a small country' and England as 'a neighbouring country'. But this just seems forced and unnatural and just made me wonder throughout why no one was allowed to say the word Wales, a question that was never answered.
Despite these criticisms, The Library Suicides is not a bad book. The plot is interesting enough to keep you reading, and the prose style is fresh and breezy.
76/140: ★★★☆☆
The flag remains that of Ceridigion, and the chosen music is Mulder and Scully by Catatonia.





Comments
Post a Comment